Chris Whitty Warns Culture War Rhetoric on Cycling Risks Public Health

Culture war narratives surrounding cycling, often characterized by stereotypes of middle-aged men in Lycra, could detrimentally impact public health by diverting attention from the broader benefits of physical activity, according to Chris Whitty, England’s chief medical officer. Speaking ahead of the NHS’s upcoming 10-year health plan, which will emphasize preventive measures, Whitty urged the public to move past media clichés and focus on indisputable data.

Whitty addressed a conference in York, emphasizing that if active travel is perceived merely as the domain of middle-aged, Lycra-clad cyclists, the significant health advantages it offers are overlooked. He stated,

“There are some areas where you can send a debate from a cultural war into a much more day-to-day one by actually saying, ‘OK guys, but this is the maths,’ and ensuring that you do so with facts which people find surprising.”

Reframing the Narrative on Active Travel

Whitty highlighted the need to challenge the cultural stereotypes that paint advocates of active transport as middle-class and entitled. He pointed out the overlooked benefits for diverse groups, such as individuals with mobility challenges.

“What they don’t see is a woman in a wheelchair who actually benefits even more from the activity that we’re talking about,”

he remarked, underscoring the inclusive potential of active travel.

Promoting physical activity is crucial, Whitty argued, as it is one of the most effective ways to maintain both physical and mental health. He advocated for integrating activity into daily routines, such as walking, cycling, or wheeling for transportation purposes.

“The people who benefit most from any form of activity are people who are doing none,”

Whitty explained, adding that those on the brink of ill health also stand to gain significantly from increased activity.

Infrastructure and Policy for Inclusive Mobility

Whitty also called on transport planners to consider not only large-scale projects like bike lanes but also smaller, everyday impediments such as uneven pavements that might deter people with mobility issues from walking short distances. He emphasized the importance of connecting key locations such as homes, shops, places of worship, and schools to encourage more people to engage in active travel.

In a notable political shift, 12 regional mayors in England, including representatives from the Conservative and Reform UK parties, have endorsed a plan to establish a “national active travel network.” This move signals a departure from the culture war-infused discourse on transport prevalent under Rishi Sunak’s government.

Political and Social Implications

Speaking alongside Whitty, junior transport minister Simon Lightwood indicated that the Labour government is adopting a different stance from Sunak’s administration.

“Gone are the days, I hope, of this poisonous rhetoric around the war on the motorist,”

Lightwood stated, highlighting a potential shift towards more inclusive and health-focused transport policies.

The announcement comes as governments and health organizations worldwide increasingly recognize the importance of active travel in combating lifestyle-related health issues. By reframing the conversation around cycling and active transport, Whitty and other advocates aim to foster a more inclusive and health-oriented approach to mobility.

As the NHS prepares to unveil its 10-year health plan, the focus on prevention and active travel is expected to play a pivotal role in shaping the future of public health in England. The initiative underscores the need for a comprehensive strategy that transcends cultural stereotypes and prioritizes the well-being of all communities.

About The Author